Hizb ut-Tahrir and Communism

Hizb ut-Tahrir (HT) is a political party, which started its activities in the Middle East, then spread worldwide. It was founded in the 1950s by Taqi al-Din al-Nabhani. Like their off-shoot (who use to call themselves) al-Muhajirun, HT is banned in the UK.

The name Hizb ut-Tahrir is from the Arabic language, hizb al-tahrir (حزب التحرير), and literally means party of liberation or liberation party. Hizb means ‘party’, al means ‘the’ and in a possessive construction works like ‘of’. Tahrir means ‘liberation’. Think of square of liberation or liberation square (ميدان التحرير) in Cairo, Egypt, i.e. Tahrir Square. This is the place where most protestors gathered during December 2010 (after which president Mubarak lost power).

I have found that Hizb ut-Tahrir shares a lot in common with so-called Bolshevism (20th century Russian Communism). Both are/were political parties/movements looking to seize political power, with the belief of restoring justice to the world.

The Hizb ut-Tahrir splinter group Muhajirun (founded by Omar Bakri) differs from HT in that they believe in establishing an Islamic State anywhere in the world; whereas HT primarily focuses on the Middle East (while recruiting elsewhere). Similarly, after Lenin’s death, the Communist Party began to have internal disagreements, the major one being between the Trotskyists (international or permanent revolution) and Stalinists (communism in one country).

When discussing democracy, Hizb ut-Tahrir will reference the origins of the word, i.e. Athens, Ancient Greece (and not so much current day democracy in the UK). They believe that voting should be done within the party alone and not by the masses. Bolsheviks saw parliamentary democracy (around 19th/20th century) as a bourgeois democracy (representing those with wealth) and believed the later Soviet system (elected worker councils) to be the real democracy. However, in practice, real power lay with the Communist party (in front of which was a public facade of Soviet democracy) and over time the people became disillusioned with Soviet rule. Meanwhile, the petty democracies of Western Europe became more inclusive of the masses.

It is the part of the methodology of Hizb ut-Tahrir that in order gain power in the Middle East, they would need to convince the military to carry out a coup d’état. This need not be bloody, but history shows us that coups are rarely bloodless (e.g. Syria, Iraq, etc). Likewise, the Bolsheviks also believed in taking power by force and did so in November 1917, resulting in over a dozen deaths. In addition, their lack of cooperation with others and disregard of the (elected) constituent assembly was followed by a bloody and painful civil war.

If/once the military coup is successful, HT’s plan is the setting up of a one-party state, i.e. Hizb ut-Tahrir, which would keep in check the caliph/president (also chosen by HT). As explained already, alongside the Soviet democratic structure, the Bolsheviks also set-up a one-party state, which is really what governed the country.

Just as the Bolsheviks saw themselves as the vanguard of the working-class, Hizb ut-Tahrir also see themselves as the vanguard of the Muslims. There is no debate outside the party, only inside. After all, they are the true intelligentsia, or so they think.

Hizb ut-Tahrir operates in semi secrecy. They organise somewhat public lectures for their supporters and recruitment purposes, and private courses for those who aspire to become members. Before the 1917 revolution, the Bolsheviks similarly operated in a semi-underground fashion.

Hizb ut-Tahrir claims to follow classical texts. For example, they will mention Imam Shafi’s Risala. However, they also contradict this book. For instance, they do not have faith in ahad hadith (prophetic narratives with fewer chains), yet Imam Shafi’s book includes a chapter on accepting habar al-wahid, which includes a narrative referring to the story of Musa and Khidr. Similarly, Bolsheviks were criticised for not having the correct interpretation of Das Kapital (Karl Marx). For example, the so-called Mensheviks believed that socialism could be achieved via a peaceful transfer of power, from the industrialists to the proletariat.

Hizb ut-Tahrir sometimes claim that they have a political focus, but in order to become a member one actually must take on their creed (aqueeda), which is not exactly Muslim orthodoxy or the majority Muslim faith. For details, ask the Sufis and the Wahhabis. The Bolsheviks were also in contrast to perhaps the majority of the social democratic movement, but perhaps since they were able to take power (for almost a century) their version of socialism is the one that became prominent in the first half of the 20th century.

Unfortunately for Hizb ut-Tahrir, their understanding of an Islamic State was never realised in the 20th century; despite their founder (apparently) saying it would take no more than 50 years. Meanwhile, the Bolsheviks were in power for over 70 years, but did not achieve socialism.

Sources:
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/jan/15/islamist-group-hizb-ut-tahrir-to-be-banned-organising-uk
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Bolshevik

Tax free shopping

Dubai has gone from tax-free to tax refund.

My understanding was, for tourists at least, that you paid no tax on goods and services. This is no longer the case, except that if you are just visiting the United Arab Emirates and leave the country within 90 days, then you can claim a refund.

Dubai put a value-added-tax (VAT), of five percent, on most purchases, which applies to residents and tourists alike (for comparison, in Egypt and Jordan it is around 15%). For instance, you can no longer buy electronics tax-free at point-of-sale.

The story is that I bought a high-specification laptop, with an English and Arabic keyboard (naturally), from Virgin Megastore. They added my passport number to the Planet Tax Free system and informed me that the refund would be automatic when I pass through the electronic gate at the airport, but this did not happen.

I learned later that I was suppose to get the refund processed before check-in, at the airport, and that I might need to show the purchased item in an unused state. That last bit would of been a inconvenience for me as I wanted to test the laptop in the hotel before taking the device out of the country. Never mind.

Could be that the system will change again, i.e. it will be automatic in future. I hope so. That would make Dubai an attractive shopping destination again.

In conclusion, I missed out on a tax refund of around $70.  Oh well, at least I can continue to write using Arabic script.

Burj Khalifa

Burj Dubai Khalifa is the tallest building in the world, but is it worth visiting?

The tower is one of the newer developments and includes residential buildings, and a mall. In Arabic, Burj means tower and Khalifa is somebody’s name. Burj Khalifa literally means the tower of Khalifa.

Actually, it was originally to be named Burj Dubai and the renaming occurred during the financial crisis of 2009 when the sheikh of Abu Dhabi, Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan, subsidised the project, thus construction was able to complete.

The view from the top is certainly interesting, but it was a crowded place (we arrived just before sunset) and I did worry about catching the Coronavirus 2019. Fortunately, I was fine. Being required to buy a ticket, I thought they would have taken a staggered approach with number of visitors, but I was wrong.

This is in contrast to my visit to Palm Island, for which the main contractor was Nakheel. Whereas for Burj Khalifa it was Emaar. However, we arrived at the Palm at around noon so a visit at non-peak hours could be the key.

With the Burj, there is a restaurant at a higher level and that could potentially be a better experience.

The tower is adjoining a shopping mall and leave this complex required a lot of patience. The queue for taxis was huge. Again, it could be timing or because of the union day celebration.

Dubai SIM card

Do buy a SIM card when you are in the United Arab Emirates (if you see a good deal). The main network operator is Etisalat, but there is also du (دو). However, if you are planning to stay less than a few days, then an e-SIM might be a better option (ask the network operator about it in your country).

If you use the free du SIM card they give you in Dubai immigration, then that might not work when you return to Dubai, (if your first arrival to Dubai was transit). If you are in Dubai for a day or two, then the du SIM card might be worth it.

When you leave Dubai via the e-gates, your free du SIM card will automatically stop working. That SIM card was registered to you when you arrived (despite it still being within its packaging).

When returning to Dubai, if you want to use the same number (that came with your free Du SIM card), then you will need to visit one of the Du company branches and it could take a while. You probably wont be able to use the same ‘free’ SIM card and may end up with a new number. There you can also buy credit (top-up), but it is only value for money for longer stays.

While in UAE, you wont be able to use WhatsApp to make calls (only texting will work). However, there are local apps that you can use for calling, e.g. Tawasal, Botim. Alternatively, a VPN would allow you call via WhatsApp.

Some of the Worst TAFL Schools Worldwide

Listed here are some of the worst language schools for Arabic language training worldwide, i.e. the TAFL centres to avoid (from better to worse):

Alexandria Centre for Languages (ACL). Only come here within a group organised by your university. Even then, do not have high expectations and forget what you saw in the brochure (it’s outdated) or heard in the presentation.

SOAS Language Centre (not to be confused with the SOAS degree/diploma programmes, which are very good – perhaps the best). Choose the language centre if you want to be continually reminded that nobody speaks modern standard Arabic or if you just want to learn random vocabulary and grammar. Taught by foreign masters/PHD students (or former students) of the university (who are primarily native Arabic speakers, not teachers). However, sometimes you get lucky. May help to run a background check on the teacher before enrolling.

– Arabica Institute (Ibn Jabal). Pay them lots of money to hear why they think School of Oriental & African Studies is bad, from a teacher who almost failed his SOAS Arabic degree; who lectures by reading from a script, i.e. the useful book you can download while you are student, but can never buy as a book.

UJLC, Jordan university. You are better off working in Dubai and learning Arabic part-time. Permanent contract teachers only get jobs here if they have a connection. Consequently, they are too lazy to teach and waste your time with a language partner scheme. Also, they are proud to be retarded.

TAFL Center, Alexandria university. If you do not mind a premature death, then this is the place for you. This place might work for you if they consider you Egyptian or if you are from the British embassy (then, while bowing down, they will probably forget to remind you that you destroyed their country and might even celebrate your monarch’s birthday). Almost forgot to mention the racism and discrimination. For more details, read on.

In 2014, I was a complete beginner to Egyptian Colloquial Arabic, yet the director (Dr Lana Habib) put me in a higher level, explaining that I was super smart.  As a consequence, I understood next to nothing during those classes and my reservations were ignored.  Later during the term, she obliged me to attend (just myself) a conference, in Colloquial Arabic, at the French Cultural Centre, claiming that I was the most suitable student. 

During the term, one of the colloquial teachers was suppose to give me extra tuition (in order to catch up with the others), but she was probably still hung up with me having eaten at a Syrian restaurant.

In 2016, Dr Lana Habib misinformed me about what programmes and levels were available at the TAFL Center. Consequently, I wasted time considering unsuitable programmes and courses, which she had encouraged me to join.

The director tried to confuse me about my level of Arabic. Eventually, I ended up enrolling in another centre at the wrong level and being cheated out of my money.

I was insulted by a teacher during a class in the TAFL Center. She questioned my British identity and laughed at my face. Then encouraged another student to laugh with her.

There appeared to be some degree of hostility towards me, perhaps because I ate in a Syrian restaurant (at the invitation of others) or that the teacher believed Britain was responsible for the destruction of Egypt.

All in all, my time was wasted in Alexandria. When I complained to the TAFL Center, instead of resolving the issue with the teacher, the director sought to hide suitable programmes and courses that I could benefit from and annoy me until I left the centre.

Summer in Marrakech

I use to be a fan of the season of summer in any part of the world, but that changed when I visited Dubai one early August. Since then, I have avoided the Gulf countries in summer and kept myself under the shade in the Middle East generally.

I wanted to get familiar with the North-West African dialects and decided to give Marrakech a try. I contacted a language centre, asking about studying the Moroccan Arabic dialect, Darija, intending some time in October. This was during the Coronavirus 2019 pandemic and I was unsure whether any centre was teaching face-to-face these days.

The director of Study Arabic Marrakech was positive and advised me that he was expecting level one students (more or less) in September, suggesting I consider this option. Determined to end my fear of contagion and be a global citizen again, I made plans to visit Morocco, informed the director and completed the online enrolment form.

Initially, it was really nice to visit Marrakech. There is a lot to see and experience. There is the old city, which is the main attraction, then there is the new city where there are nice cafes, such as Cappuccino near Avenue Echouhada. Also, there is the countryside and mountains nearby.

However, due to the summer heat, I was unable to sleep. Also, I have never been a fan of air conditioning, but without it, being indoors was unbearable. Anywhere north of Marrakech would of been perfect. During the months of July, August and September, if you are planning to study, then Marrakech is better avoided.  Having said that, the city is full of tourists throughout summer and if you are unlike me, then Marrakech will probably work for you – any time of year.

At the language centre, which turned out to be very genuine, all was well except that the other beginner students had not turned up. One was said to have arrived in Marrakech, but still sorting out accommodation, apparently. There was a level 2+, but the director’s opinion was correct, it would be counter productive. After losing a couple of days, the directors suggested I could take a one to one class, but pay for group tuition. If the others arrive, then great. If not, then we carry on. Sounded like a good deal and I accepted.

Unfortunately, I was unable to find a cheap and comfortable hotel near the centre, which was in the suburbs, but eventually I settled in a hotel nearer to the city centre and found, to my surprise, taking a taxi everyday to be a way easier process (civilised) compared to other locations in the Middle East. Just needed to agree a price before getting in. I must admit, I had some interesting conversations with the drivers and they spoke good modern standard Arabic, or some mixture of the former and Darija. Most importantly, I understood them and they could understand me.

Another activity one can do in Marrakech is a bicycle tour of the city. I booked this with Pikala Bikes and it was certainly the highlight of my trip. Another trip they do is an Eco lodge visit near the Sahara. There are often tour groups organising hikes in the Moroccan deserts and the climbing of Mount Toubkal, a popular activity. Marrakech is often the starting point of such trips.

You can also enrol at Study Arabic Marrakech for the long term and they teach Modern Standard Arabic too. Alternatively, you might want to try out other language centres around the country, while exploring the rest of Morocco. By train, you can get to Casablanca in three hours.

Should one learn Arabic in Marrakech? There are a couple of language centres in this city, including one that teaches Berber, and the Study Arabic Marrakech centre is perfect if you want to study for a few days only.

Great Arab Revolt Centennial

It was suppose to be my last day in Jordan.  However, due to the Great Arab Revolt centennial celebration, I almost ended up getting stuck again in Amman. 

Many people were celebrating and making their way to a party.  Consequently, the roads were choc-o-bloc with vehicles and my already booked taxi arrived late (to pick me up).  Fortunately, the driver said he knew a short-cut to the airport.

At the airport, (at least one minute before check-in officially closes), the Qatar airline counter staff member informed me that check-in was closed.  Internally, I had already resigned to the eventuality that I might remain in Jordan indefinitely.  However, I explained what had happened and, to my relief, she checked me in.

Had I missed my flight, what would I have done that day?  Celebrate with the locals?  Probably not.  I would have booked the next flight back to the UK or made my way to Cairo to complete my learning.

Some admirers of the Ottoman empire believe that it was primarily defeated by the Saudis (in collaboration by the Wahabis) in collusion with the British empire.  However, this is far from the truth.  Unfortunately, certain Middle Eastern political movements/parties further compound the myth through their publications.

For instance, as will be explained below, the book How the Khilafah was Destroyed, by Abdul Qadeem Zallum (endorsed by Hizb ut-Tahrir) contains a number of misunderstandings.  

Let us begin with ibn Abd al-Wahhab, his supporters would say that in the 18th century (backed by the Saudis) he established law and order in the Najd area (not part of the Ottoman state) and secured the pilgrim routes to Mecca and Medina, and in his letters made it clear that it is wrong to rebel against the rulers (unless they call to sin).

According to M. S. al-Munajjid, ibn Abd al-Wahhaab said to the people of al-Qaseem: “I believe that it is obligatory to hear and obey the leaders of the Muslims, whether they are righteous or immoral, so long as they do not enjoin disobedience towards Allaah. Whoever has become Caliph and the people have given him their support and accepted him, even if he has gained the position of caliph by force, is to be obeyed and it is haraam to rebel against him.” (Majmoo’at Mu’allafaat al-Shaykh, 5/11).

Actually, Kuwait was not under Ottoman rule in 1788.  In the 20th century, the Saudis (with their Bedouin army – Ikhwan) established their current kingdom, but they played a minor role in World War One (possibly a single skirmish with an Ottoman garrison, then war with Kuwait).

They were more concerned with local conflicts (e.g. Rashid dynasty). As far as I know, the Saudis never reached Amman, let alone Damascus. At the southern border of Jordan, they were bombed by the British Royal Air Force.

As for Abdul-Aziz ibn Muhammad, while it is clear that ibn Saud was not an ally of the Ottomans and might of had negotiations with the British, it has never been proven that he was an agent of the British empire.

The Sharifian Army of Mecca, who were the leaders of the Arab Revolt (1916), were bribed with gold and supplied with explosives (by the British empire). Their aim was a United Arab Kingdom, perhaps with Damascus as its capitol.  Faisal (or his army) made it to Damascus.

Later, Faisal was made king of Iraq (by the British).  His brother Abdullah was made king of Transjordan.  Apparently, their father, in the Hijaz, al-Sharif Hussein bin Ali proclaimed himself caliph in 1924.  Soon after, the Hejazi Army (after defeating the Ottomans in Mecca and Medina) lost the Hijaz to the Saudis.

Today, the remaining Sharifian royal family rule the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.   One need only visit the Martyrs museum in Amman or the World War One memorial in Salt, to understand that the Arab Revolt was led by Sharifian forces (initially near the Suez Canal, supported by British forces) and not by Saudi Bedouins in Najd.

Sources:
A History of the Modern Middle East, William L. Cleveland
Saudi Arabia: a case study in development, Fouad al-Fars
The Road to Mecca, Muhammad Asad
A History of Jordan, Philip Robins
A history of Iraq, Charles R. H. Tripp
https://islamqa.info/en/answers/9243/did-shaykh-muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhaab-rebel-against-the-ottoman-caliphate-and-what-was-the-reason-for-its-fall
https://www.britannica.com/place/Kuwait/History
https://cdn.britannica.com/89/4789-050-B6176F52/Expansion-Ottoman-Empire.jpg
https://cdn.britannica.com/40/131540-050-EFC5F6A7/Map-Arabia-insets-edition-Palestine-Jerusalem-Encyclopaedia-1902.jpg
http://www.kinghussein.gov.jo/his_arabrevolt.html
https://cdn.britannica.com/49/183749-050-8A2CE93D/World-Data-Locator-Map-Saudi-Arabia.jpg
https://cdn.britannica.com/95/5795-050-F7E34466/Saudi-Arabia-map-features-locator.jpg

Alexandria Centre for Languages

After visiting Pharos university I came across the Alexandria Centre for Languages (ACL) where finally I found out what happened to the SOAS students (School of Oriental & African Studies, University of London).  Apparently, since 2014 or earlier, for their year abroad, they had a choice between ACL, an-Najah university in Palestine and Qasid in Jordan.

The SOAS students appeared to be a lively bunch and on the first day spoke to me in Arabic, which naturally inclined me towards them.  I worked out a deal with the director, Magda Abou Youssef, that I could try out the course for one week, which I paid for, and then decide whether to join the SOAS programme or not.  I also took the placement test.

Continue reading “Alexandria Centre for Languages”

TAFL Center, Alexandria University

The last time I was here, one of the teachers insulted me in class.

In early January, while searching for a suitable center for teaching Arabic as a foreign language, I ended up returning to the TAFL Center (within the Faculty of Arts, Alexandria University).  The last time I was there, one of the teachers had a problem and insulted me in the class.  Thought it best to clear the issue before enrolling.  Now I felt forced.

Continue reading “TAFL Center, Alexandria University”

Out of the frying pan and into the fire

This is about the ‘prison’ in Sidi Bishr.

It was near a square (Mohummed Nageeb) facing the corniche.  Potentially, it is a good area, except that the official refuse collection does not keep up with the amount of rubbish that accumulates.

I was sharing an apartment with my new Chinese friend who told me it was a clean, beautiful, fully furnished and working apartment.  The main attraction of this flatmate was that he use to speak to me in Arabic, seemed passionate about his studies and tried to enjoy himself in Egypt (back in 2014).  Sadly, this was no longer the case.

Continue reading “Out of the frying pan and into the fire”